The real reason Leonardo DiCaprio so enraged Megyn Kelly 

Leonardo DiCaprio, the leading man of Titanic, The Wolf of Wall Street, and so many other movies, recently celebrated his 52nd birthday.

He did this with a decadent bash in Los Angeles, that great pit of iniquity. The bacchanal was attended by 50 Cent, Justin Trudeau, Tobey Maguire, Al Pacino, and other well-known rogues.

The guest list also included a busload of winsome young women. They were caught on video, as they descended from their mode of transportation, each one more nubile and attractive than the previous one.

Were the young women there to mingle? If so—in what capacity? Were sexual acts on the agenda? No one could say for certain—but there were certainly no ironclad guarantees against unlawful carnal knowledge taking place behind the closed doors of the party venue.

As is so often the case nowadays, the internet went nuts, starting with the mainstream media. The headlines blared, “Creepy!”, “Pervy!”, “Pathetic!”

Most journalists agreed that the young women appeared to all be of legal age, and no laws were likely broken. But this was the sort of thing that just shouldn’t happen in 2026—an era of #MeToo, gender-neutral terminology, and endless fretting about power imbalances in sexual relationships. Why the hell wasn’t someone doing something? How could such unbridled debauchery happen in these buttoned-down, guilt-ridden times of ours?

For once, the nattering class on both the right and the left found agreement. They all concurred that Leonardo DiCaprio was a cad, a perv, a creep for being so attracted to so many young women. Thousands of fingers wagged in DiCaprio’s direction.

But no one wagged their fingers more emphatically than 56-year-old Megyn Kelly, a conservative pundit and former commentator at Fox News. Kelly devoted most of a podcast to lambasting DiCaprio. Kelly went on such a tirade, that her tirade became a news story in its own right.

Noting that Leonardo DiCaprio “used to be hot,” Kelly described the present version of the star as “fat” and “bloated.” She also hinted that DiCaprio might be a secret drug addict—though she delivered this accusation without any real evidence and a large disclaimer. (Megyn Kelly used to be an attorney.)

She made so many references to Leonardo DiCaprio’s weight that her guest, Dr. Drew Pinsky, started to get squirmy. If Kelly had been a man making such remarks about a woman, the internet would have gone apoplectic with charges of “fat-shaming.”

I realize that in her role as a professional pundit, minding other people’s business is part of Megyn Kelly’s job description. But Kelly’s reproach came from someplace intimate and personal. More on that shortly.

**View NO SURE THING at Amazon**

A part of me agrees with Megyn Kelly’s criticism, where Leonardo DiCaprio’s conduct toward women is concerned. DiCaprio has long been one of the most eligible men in the world. It is no exaggeration to say that—in his prime, anyway—Leonardo DiCaprio could have married just about anyone.

And no one begrudged DiCaprio an attractive, even younger, partner. If I were him, I would have settled down with someone like British actress Hermione Corfield and called it a day.

But DiCaprio has turned his middle years into one long extension of male adolescence. The commonly circulated remark that he doesn’t date women over twenty-five is a slight exaggeration. His current love interest, Italian fashion model Vittoria Ceretti, is 28 years old, after all. But Leonardo DiCaprio does seem to regard young women—or at least their company—as a commodity to be consumed. His recent birthday bash is yet further evidence of that.

Leonardo DiCaprio, moreover, clearly doesn’t care what his critics think. This is another aspect of his behavior that infuriates the guardians of proper behavior in our culture. Leonardo DiCaprio, unlike so many of us in these politically correct times, is impervious to shaming. He continues to party on as if it’s the height of the 1970s, and his home is Hugh Hefner’s Playboy Mansion.

I can remember late 1997 and early 1998, though, back when Leonardo DiCaprio became an international star with the movie Titanic. DiCaprio was then in his 20s and the epitome of the “pretty boy.” He also had the lead role in a romantic movie that wasn’t absolutely horrible—as romantic movies go. I knew women back then who saw Titanic four, five, and six times (I knew one woman who saw it eight times—and not on streaming or cable, but at the theater.)

Which brings us back to Megyn Kelly. What was she doing in 1997-98? Megyn Kelly was then in her late twenties. She was an associate attorney at a Chicago law firm. She was doing well in the world, but she was still unknown beyond her immediate social and professional circles.

It is not difficult to imagine Megyn Kelly as one of those wide-eyed young women in the cinema audience in late 1997 or early 1998, mooning over Leonardo DiCaprio in his role as Jack Dawson, the beautifully handsome, doomed love interest of Rose DeWitt Bukater in Titanic. My, how the young women and girls loved him back then!

And just look at that same man now. Would Leonardo DiCaprio respect the 56-year-old Megyn Kelly for all her many accomplishments? Or would he prefer to cavort with a busload of young bimbos? Leonardo DiCaprio has already given us his answer.

**View THE WOMAN IN CROSLEY TOWER at Amazon**

Megyn Kelly’s criticisms are, as I’ve acknowledged, not entirely unreasonable. But this is the sort of thing that goes both ways. Poke around on the internet. You’ll find that there are plenty of men who are exasperated with women who endlessly fawn over the bad boys, and obsess about superficial factors like men’s height on dating apps. Both of the sexes frequently disappoint the other when it comes to their priorities. Men think that women should prefer a certain type of man—but alas—many of them prefer an entirely different kind of man. Many women are similarly disappointed to discover that a successful 50-something man is still drawn to the sort of woman who caught his eye thirty years prior.

And what about DiCaprio’s weight? No one would accuse Leonardo DiCaprio of gymmaxing. In fact, Leonardo DiCaprio doesn’t look like he’s ever seen the inside of a Planet Fitness or similar workout facility. But then again, he never did.

Leonardo DiCaprio has what was called, a few years ago, a “dad bod.” He could stand to drop a few pounds, no argument there, but he doesn’t stand out as obese for a man his age by contemporary American standards. (If Megyn Kelly thinks that Leonardo DiCaprio is obese, she should come to Ohio.)

What infuriates Megyn Kelly is not that Leonardo DiCaprio is out of shape. She is enraged by the fact that, at his age, with his level of physical fitness, he has the gall to stroll shirtless on well-photographed beaches, hand in hand with a slender woman who is more than young enough to be his daughter. Many men, and not just men over fifty, go to the gym in order to remain attractive to the opposite sex. Leonardo DiCaprio knows that he doesn’t have to do that. He can be careless about his physical condition and women will continue to swoon over him, both for who he is and who he used to be.

But Megyn Kelly is not angry primarily because Leonardo DiCaprio is engaging in more hedonistic pleasure than any 52-year-old man ought to be entitled to. Nor is she concerned about preserving the virtues of the young women who were brought to the aging star’s birthday party.

Megyn Kelly is angry because she thinks that Leonardo DiCaprio—a man that a former version of her almost certainly admired—turned out to be something other than what she fantasized him to be. Something other than what she thought he should be.

And yes, I get that, just like I get her many criticisms of Leonardo DiCaprio and his lifestyle.

Members of the opposite sex often disappoint all of us—both in what they become and what they prioritize in romantic partners. Perhaps Megyn Kelly, at the age of fifty-six, didn’t fully grasp this before. But she definitely realizes it now, courtesy of Leonardo DiCaprio.

-ET

I live in Appalachia

I only recently learned that Clermont County, Ohio—where I have long resided—is part of Appalachia.

But it’s true. Clermont County represents the westernmost fringe of that region.

Neighboring Hamilton County (Cincinnati) is diverse. Hamilton County includes neighborhoods too dangerous to drive through during the daylight hours, as well as multimillion-dollar subdivisions.

**SAVE AT AMAZON on books about Appalachia**

And so it is with Clermont County. There are some rural areas that haven’t changed much since the 1970s. On the other hand, Clermont County is one of the fastest-growing regions in the Greater Cincinnati area. There are multimillion-dollar subdivisions here, too.

Other places I’ve lived

In previous years of my adult life, I’ve lived in:

  • Anderson Township, Ohio
  • Wilmington, Ohio
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • Chicago, Illinois

I’ve found something to like about every place I’ve lived… except Chicago. Chicago is a large, unpleasant city with horrible weather. I lived there for a while in 1991. I have avoided going back since then, for fear of being trapped there by some unforeseen circumstance.

If Hell exists, they probably keep it somewhere in Chicago.

-ET

Arnold Schwarzenegger speaking German

Like many ‘80s kids, I remember Arnold Schwarzenegger as a central figure in the pop culture of my youth. First he was Conan the Barbarian. Later in the 1980s, he was The Terminator. Schwarzenegger also starred in a handful of one-off action films.

I was interested in weightlifting and fitness, and Arnold Schwarzenegger had only recently ended his bodybuilding career. At that time, he was in early middle age, and still considered one of the world’s top bodybuilders. So I was exposed to him in my reading of Muscle & Fitness, too.

Arnold Schwarzenegger has never hidden his immigrant status. (That would be kind of difficult, given that he speaks English with a German accent.) But he has always been adamant about emphasizing his adopted American identity, and expresses gratitude for the opportunities he found in the United States. Schwarzenegger was a two-term governor of California from 2003 to 2011.

We are so accustomed to hearing him speak German-accented English that it would be easy to believe that German-accented English is his mother tongue. But German was Schwarzenegger’s first language and he still speaks it on occasion when he visits Europe. Below is a video of Schwarzenegger speaking his native language.

(**Save on German language learning products at Amazon**)

Arnold Schwarzenegger speaks a rural Styrian dialect, which is associated with the Bavarian region of Austria. But if you have a working knowledge of standard German, you should have little trouble understanding him.

-ET

Camille Herron: yet another OnlyFans story

Camille Herron, an ultramarathon runner, has joined the ranks of female celebrities with OnlyFans accounts. Herron took this step after losing several more conventional athletic brand sponsorships.

Herron is a “hotwife”. This means that although she’s married, she has intimate relations with other men. Part of the hotwife culture, as I understand it, is that she does so with the full knowledge and consent of her husband. This gives us some idea of the sort of content one might find on Herron’s OnlyFans account.

No shaming here for Herron. One basic rule of economics is that where sufficient demand exists, one eventually finds supply.

It is rather to the demand side which I wish to speak. I grew up in an era with a different attitude toward pornography. Yes—you looked at Playboy and Penthouse when you were thirteen years old. But there was always something pathetic about being too interested in “naked pictures” (as opposed to the real McCoy). And perhaps there is something pathetic about a society in which millions of men are drawn to this option. (An estimated 65 million to 82 million U.S. men subscribe to OnlyFans.)

It amazes me that so many men are willing to plunk down large sums of money to watch women—whom they will never even meet—have sex with other men.

-ET

The Ohio governor’s race and the human factor

As many of you will know, Democrat Amy Acton won the race for Ohio governor. This will be the first time Ohio has had a Democratic governor since 2006. 

I have no idea what kind of a governor Amy Acton will be. But in the above video, we see why Acton won a state that should have been a shoo-in for the Republicans.

This year, Ohio had to choose between two candidates who were unknown commodities in elected office. Amy Acton came across as likable. Vivek Ramaswamy came across as conniving an mean-spirited—especially with that ad featuring Acton’s estranged mother.

Ramaswamy could have disavowed the ad, blamed it on an overzealous staffer, and apologized. Damage control might have been possible. Instead, he chose to double down on his mistake.

Ramaswamy became a textbook example of a candidate failing to “read the room”.

Not only do I not know how Acton will perform as governor—I can’t even say for certain if she is sincere. (I tend to think she is, but who knows?)

Acton, though, ran a better campaign. She seemed to understand that in this race between two unknowns, undecided voters would tend to vote for the candidate who came across as more human–a contest which she resoundingly won.

-ET

Donovan’s Reef: John Wayne, John Ford, and a comedic adventure that goes awry

It’s fairly rare for me not to like a John Wayne movie. But I didn’t like Donovan’s Reef (1963), the Duke’s final collaboration with director John Ford.

There’s a story in here, but the movie is kind of a mess. And I didn’t care for the film’s Kennedy-era slapstick humor.

This is an unusual movie for John Wayne, starting with the premise. In Donovan’s Reef,  Wayne plays “Guns” Donovan, a World War II Navy veteran who runs a waterfront saloon on a French Polynesian island. His old shipmate “Boats” Gilhooley (Lee Marvin) comes ashore in time to observe their shared birthday in the usual fashion, with a barroom brawl. The third member of the group, “Doc” Dedham (Jack Warden), is the island doctor and the father of three children.

Then word comes from Boston that Doc’s grown daughter Amelia (Elizabeth Allen) is coming to the island. She has never met her father, and she wants to find out whether he’s fit to inherit a controlling interest in the family shipping company. With Doc away tending to patients on neighboring islands, Donovan decides to pass off the doctor’s three children as his own until Doc gets back.

Hijinks ensue. So, too, does the romance plot between Wayne and his much younger female costar (a predictable formula in most of Wayne’s later films).

Regular readers will know that political correctness for its own sake is not my shtick. Golden Age American cinema often portrays Native Americans, Asians, and other minorities in ways that would not be acceptable today. It’s fine to acknowledge that; but if you’re going to be clutching pearls throughout an entire film, it’s not worth the trouble of watching it.

Donovan’s Reef, however, overflows with Orientalism that must have been clichéd even for its time. The film contains scores of jabbering, grinning Asian stereotypes. This was an attempt at comedy. I don’t have a problem with politically incorrect comedy so long as it’s funny. The racial clichés in Donovan’s Reef seldom produced much humor.

The film contains far too many unnecessary fight scenes between Wayne and Lee Marvin… between Wayne and drunken sailors… etc.

The one high point in the movie is some of the dialogue between John Wayne and Elizabeth Allen. I wish this part of the movie had been more developed.

***

Like I said at the outset, this movie had some potential. I had the impression throughout that John Ford couldn’t decide what kind of movie he wanted to make. In 1963, the film was billed as a “big adventure.” Ford erred, in my opinion, when he decided to make Donovan’s Reef a comedy, too. Everything went awry from there.

-ET

Save on Amazon:

**View JOHN WAYNE: THE LIFE AND LEGEND by Scott Eyman on Amazon**

Public schools face an existential crisis

Fairfield City Schools, a school district in the Greater Cincinnati area, must make $11 million in cuts for the 2027-28 academic year.

The cuts are old news. Fairfield cut 84.5 positions for the 2022-23 academic year. These additional, upcoming cuts are the result of a failed tax levy this past Election Day.

The debate over school funding can be heard throughout the Buckeye State. It has many components.

I’ve written before about the unintended consequences EdChoice has brought to Catholic schools. (EdChoice, ironically, has mostly served to make Catholic schools too expensive for working-class parents.) EdChoice also deprives the public schools of funding.

I’ve written about the growth of homeschooling—about which I have my doubts.

Finally, public schools also face a crisis of falling birthrates.

The larger crisis, however, is that a majority of parents and taxpayers no longer believe in the soundness of public education, or in the competence of the people managing and teaching in public schools.

This is not some “old Boomer” talking. (By the way, I’m not a Boomer. I’m actually a Gen Xer—though I’m occasionally mistaken for a Boomer.) It isn’t Boomers or Gen Xers who are withdrawing their kids from public schools and sending them to private schools or educating them at home. Do the math. Boomers haven’t had school-aged children since the 1990s. Most of my Gen X friends are now grandparents.

No—the abandonment of public schools is being driven by the choices of Millennial and older Gen Z parents.

These are the supposedly progressive, secular generations. And yet, they’re giving public schools a thumbs down.

This means an existential crisis for public education, at least the type of public education that so many of us knew as children. And though I am frequently conservative and grumpy, I make this assessment without any glee or schadenfreude.

On the contrary, I recognize public schools as a necessary leveling factor in our society. I was fortunate enough to attend parochial schools (decades before the voucher system or EdChoice, by the way). But my father and all four of my grandparents were educated in quality public schools. None of them would have risen far in the world without that opportunity.

How to fix public education from the inside out? That’s a much bigger question and a very long discussion. But it is a discussion that we need to have.

-ET

Lauren Mayfield and the double-edged sword of performative outrage

This past week, the internet exploded over a video showing two young women at the University of Mississippi (Ole Miss) making monkey noises in a doorcam on their way out (or perhaps on their way in) for the evening. Having seen the videos, one suspects that alcohol was involved.

I’ve heard competing narratives about the true intentions of the young women. (According to one account, they made these noises at multiple, random doors.)

But for the sake of argument, let’s just assume that this was a puerile racist joke.

Administration authorities at Ole Miss could have handled this incident. It wasn’t a mass murder. It wasn’t even an assault. It was a stupid prank that might have been racially motivated. Yes, there should have been consequences. But the world wasn’t coming to an end.

The righteous indignation of the internet, however, would not be silenced. Every other person on social media decided that they had to make a video or a Facebook post about how much this incident enraged them. Many pearls were clutched.

As a result, at least one of the young women who made the monkey noises, Lauren Mayfield, became a cause célèbre for certain factions on the political right. An online fundraiser was started in her name.

According to the most recent figure I’ve seen, the fundraiser has brought in $87,000. It could go as high as $200,000.

Lauren Mayfield’s academic career at Ole Miss may have come to an end, but she’ll be making a tidy sum in exchange.

What outrages deserve the bulk of our attention? What should trigger us the most?

Also this past week, in Mahoning County, Ohio, a 15-year-old girl was beaten to near unconsciousness on a school bus by one of her peers.

This incident also had a racial dynamic. But this time, the racial dynamic did not fit the popular, politically fashionable narrative. And so the beating of a 15-year-old girl was virtually ignored, while the internet went insane over monkey noises.

-ET

Coed high school football? 

Turpin High School, a school near the high school I attended in days of yore, has a girl playing on the [boys’] junior varsity team.

This is being celebrated as “breaking down barriers”. I only hope it doesn’t involve breaking bones, before the season is over.

I bring some firsthand knowledge to this discussion. The question here goes far beyond the current, (and interminable) political debate about gender identity.

I played freshman football. (Huge disclaimer: I was not very good at it, though I did arguably excel at the position of third string left tackle.) I didn’t find my niche in high school sports until I discovered running.

That said, I did enough of it to get a taste for it. As I recall, high school football is a physically demanding, sometimes dangerous undertaking, and all that testosterone gives boys a definite advantage.

I’m also a big fan of Title IX, which guarantees girls and women their own athletic spaces. If there’s a desire for a “rougher” sport for girls, it would make a lot more sense to establish a girl’s rugby league or lacrosse (which I believe Turpin already has).

My understanding is that while Forest Hills in Cincinnati is a solid school district, the district also has its share of progressive ideologues. I hope it doesn’t take a serious student injury to make common sense prevail.

I hope, moreover, that this works out in every way for the lone girl on the boy’s football team. But let the record state that I have my doubts about this.

-ET

Read THE WITCHES OF HARMONY in Kindle+

I am drawn to foreign locations. Some of you know that I’m an avid, lifelong student of foreign languages.

At the same time, travel involves many unknowns. There is a lot that can go wrong… especially if you encounter supernatural entities at your destination.

That’s the idea behind my Terrifying Travels series.

The most recent addition to the series is THE WITCHES OF HARMONY, which involves restless 17th-century spirits in the fictional Greater Boston town of Harmony, Massachusetts. Check it out on Amazon. (This title is presently enrolled in Kindle+, too.)

Amazon book description:

Some business trips are better left unbooked.

Bill Preston has spent years traveling the country for his job, working trade shows in convention centers from one coast to the other. So when he’s assigned to an industrial expo in Harmony, Massachusetts, he expects another routine week on the road.

Then a coworker warns him about Harmony.

He won’t say exactly what happened there. Only that he never wants to go back.

Bill soon discovers that Harmony is a picture-perfect New England town with a history no one wants to discuss. There are whispered stories about witches who escaped the Salem trials—only to meet a more terrible fate in Harmony.

There are warnings not to go outside after dark.

And there are things in Harmony that only certain people can see.

Bill considers himself a rational man. He doesn’t believe in witches, ghosts, or ancient curses.

But something in Harmony has noticed him.

And before this business trip is over, Bill may discover that some places never escape their past.

The Witches of Harmony is a supernatural horror tale of haunted history, business travel, and a New England town with a secret it has been keeping for more than three hundred years.

Why dinosaur encounters scare us so much 

I recently produced a story for my YouTube channel called “Ohiosaurus Rex.” This very short piece depicts a married couple’s encounter with a dinosaur during a drive through the Ohio countryside. I explain this unusual event with a time slip.

Then, lo and behold, I find that Warner Brothers Entertainment had a similar idea. A new movie called The End of Oak Street, starring Anne Hathaway, is about dinosaurs invading the suburbs.

No hard feelings. I didn’t plagiarize Warner Brothers and they didn’t plagiarize me. The idea of modern-day humans coming face-to-face with giant carnivorous reptiles has been a universal story concept since dinosaurs were first discovered more than one hundred years ago. This is the basis for the entire Jurassic Park franchise. But maybe Michael Crichton got the idea from Land of the Lost, a TV series I remember from my childhood.

No one owns the idea of “dinosaurs versus humans.” Every creator leaves their unique stamp on the idea. The End of Oak Street promises to be a very good movie, based on the online clip. And it will be a very different movie from any of the Jurassic Park films.

Why do dinosaurs fascinate and scare us so much? They tap into a primeval fear, that of being prey. Modern humans are at the top of the food chain. Yes, we may become prey in very specific and rare instances when we encounter polar bears, great white sharks, or Nile crocodiles. Those are predicaments that most of us can easily avoid.

But what about a giant reptile that crashes through a fence? There is nothing quite like that anywhere on Earth—nor has there been, since the dawn of humankind.

I’m looking forward to seeing The End of Oak Street. I would also speculate that I’ll be returning to dinosaur stories myself. There are just too many possibilities to pass up, where dinosaurs and humans are concerned.

-ET

The dubious motives (and illogic) of the child-hating

Vogue Australia asks, When did it become socially acceptable to vocally dislike kids?

Source: Vogue, Facebook

I certainly have some observations and a few opinions to offer:

The anti-child sentiment is an idea that rears its ugly head in our culture every generation or so. A version of this existed in the 1970s.

There’s a difference between saying “being a parent is not appropriate to my individual circumstances”— and actively disliking children.

I’m not a parent, but I also recognize that people getting married and having kids is… well, kind of what makes the world go around. If no one has any kids, then the human race dies.

(But maybe that is what the anti-child people consider to be an optimal outcome. There definitely is a perverse, nihilistic streak in this movement.)

Another irony is that so many of the people who are virulently anti-child are dog fanatics. They’re basically saying that they don’t want a human child… but they’re willing to sign on to the care of a furry, unsanitary, slobbering creature that is the equivalent of a permanent 2-year-old.

They make no sense.

-ET

The economics of Alice Little

Since Meta has been messing with the algorithms, some very random stuff has been coming up in my personal Facebook feed. Among this miscellanea are the Facebook posts of Alice Little. Ms. Little is a courtesan at one of Nevada’s legal brothels. In other words, she’s a legal sex worker.

I will admit—I enjoy reading Alice’s posts. She’s funny, unabashed, and far less depressing than most of the random digital creators who show up in my Facebook feed.

Source: Alice Little, Facebook

The legalization of sex work is a topic that comes up from time to time in our public square. The world’s oldest profession has few friends among our political class. Republicans don’t like commercialized sex because it involves sex. Democrats don’t like commercialized sex because it involves free enterprise. The political proponents of legalization or decriminalization are a hodgepodge of politicians from both the left and the right fringes—sex-positive feminists on the left, and libertarians on the right.

The arguments against the legalization of sex work used to be based on commonly shared cultural and sexual norms. That argument might have had some validity in the 1950s. But never in my lifetime have Americans been able to agree on any common standard that might reasonably be called public morality.

Nowadays the argument is more likely to hinge on issues of power imbalances and real or imagined exploitation. The argument here is that no woman would ever freely decide to exchange sexual favors for money. Ergo, all sex workers are under the control of sadistic pimps lurking somewhere in the shadows.

Alice Little is not only active on Facebook, she has also been interviewed by the mainstream media. She charges four figures, makes tons of money, and is very adamant that she’s doing what she wants to do.

None of the above is meant to imply that sex work should become a mainstream career. Men simply cannot do it. (The demand for male services is virtually nonexistent.) The vast majority of women would likely have no interest in doing Alice Little’s job for any amount of money.

Nor are all men lining up to be clients—and certainly not at those prices. I have no interest in paying Alice Little’s high fees in exchange for access to her company. (You see, I would consider that degrading and insulting to me. What am I—chopped liver?)

But unlike so many busybodies out there, I have no desire to restrict the personal choices of others.

And this is really the crux of the issue. Consenting adults are either free to make their own decisions, or they’re not. We either trust women with individual agency, or we don’t. Either you own your sex life—or the government does.

-ET

Was 1980s music better?

Such is the question that I considered in the following video. The video transcript follows. 

Transcript: “Was 1980s music better?”

The other day, I saw a question being debated on the Internet. It’s a question that people have brought up to me from time to time:

Was music in the 1980s objectively better than the music being produced today?

It’s a complicated question, but I think there’s a case to be made that the mainstream music marketplace of the 1980s was better than the one we have today.

Let me explain why.

Taylor Swift, Harry Styles, and Today’s Popular Music

I know a group of Gen Z young women who are always telling me about the music they’re listening to. They’re into Taylor Swift, Harry Styles, Olivia Rodrigo, and other contemporary performers.

I’ve gone out and sampled the music of these artists. And I don’t necessarily think they’re bad.

Let’s take Taylor Swift, for example. There’s a perception out there, particularly in certain political contexts, that older men reflexively dislike Taylor Swift.

I don’t dislike Taylor Swift.

I do, however, think that her music is mediocre by the standards of the 1980s.

If Taylor Swift had broken out in 1983, I suspect she would have risen to approximately the level of Debbie Gibson.

And there’s nothing wrong with that. Debbie Gibson certainly had an audience back then, particularly among younger female listeners.

But Debbie Gibson was never the cultural phenomenon that Taylor Swift has become. And I don’t believe Taylor Swift would have become the same cultural phenomenon if she’d started her career in 1983.

Why not?

When I listen to today’s most popular younger musicians, their music strikes me as bland. Not necessarily bad, but bland.

In some ways, it reminds me of the contemporary Hollywood movie industry. We get one superhero film after another, or the fiftieth installment of some franchise that began in the 1970s or 1980s.

Much of this entertainment seems designed to appeal to the lowest common denominator.

It’s entertainment that relatively few people will passionately hate, but that can also be difficult to passionately love.

I watched a Harry Styles music video the other day. It wasn’t objectively awful. But it wasn’t objectively great, either.

So what’s changed?

The Musical Diversity of the 1980s

To understand the difference, we need to go back to the music industry of the 1980s.

This was the heyday of MTV, back when MTV actually played music videos. It was also the heyday of the shopping mall record store and the album-buying culture.

Record companies were investing in an incredibly diverse range of musical acts.

And when I say diverse, I mean that in the best possible sense of the word.

First, there was diversity in the sense that we most commonly use the word today.

This was a period when numerous Black performers were achieving tremendous mainstream success.

Whitney Houston broke out in the mid-1980s. Billy Ocean was huge. Michael Jackson was one of the biggest stars in the world.

Latin performers such as Gloria Estefan also achieved mainstream success during this period.

All-female bands like the Bangles were enormously popular.

And contrary to some contemporary perceptions of the 1980s, LGBTQ performers could achieve mainstream success, too.

Now, I’m not suggesting that the 1980s were some sort of paradise for LGBTQ people. Individual experiences undoubtedly varied, depending on where people lived, their families, and their circumstances.

But in the mainstream music industry, performers like Boy George and Culture Club were achieving massive commercial success.

Culture Club was among the early acts to become major stars through MTV.

All of that was happening in the 1980s.

But there was another kind of diversity, too: musical diversity.

If you liked heavy metal, as I did, you had bands like Def Leppard, with their highly polished, commercially accessible sound.

If you wanted something a little rawer, you had AC/DC.

Bruce Springsteen was enjoying a major resurgence in popularity.

There was also the entire British New Wave movement, with groups like A Flock of Seagulls.

I was never a particularly enthusiastic fan of British New Wave music, but plenty of other people were.

The point is that whatever your musical tastes, you could probably find something you liked.

And, crucially, you could find it in the mainstream commercial marketplace.

That’s an important distinction.

What Changed in the Music Industry?

The economics of the music business changed dramatically after the 1980s.

This is a complicated subject that could easily justify an entire separate essay, but one major turning point came around 2000, with Napster and the rise of Internet file sharing.

Consumers became less willing to purchase albums, and the traditional economics of recorded music were disrupted.

As the business changed, record companies became more cautious about where they invested their money.

When a company was going to invest heavily in a performer, it increasingly wanted someone who could appeal to the broadest possible audience.

Someone like Taylor Swift.

The problem with this approach is that when you try to make any form of art appeal to too many people, you risk removing the very qualities that make it distinctive.

You sand off all the rough edges.

Consider AC/DC.

I’ve discussed AC/DC in another video, and one thing that strikes me about the band is just how distinctive its sound is.

AC/DC certainly isn’t going to appeal to everyone.

But if you like that kind of music, there’s nothing quite like AC/DC.

And that distinctiveness is part of what makes the band so appealing to its fans.

The same principle applies to other forms of art, including fiction and filmmaking.

When you try to please everyone, you risk producing something that nobody particularly loves.

But Isn’t There More Musical Diversity Today?

At this point, someone is probably going to object.

They’ll say that there are thousands upon thousands of independent musicians producing every conceivable kind of music today.

And they’re right.

You can go onto YouTube, Spotify, and other streaming platforms and find musicians working in practically every genre imaginable.

In that sense, there may actually be more musical diversity today than there was in the 1980s.

I don’t dispute that.

But there’s a problem: discoverability.

When you have a million bands competing for attention on YouTube and Spotify, how does the average listener find something new?

This brings us to the issue of curation.

One of the valuable features of the 1980s music industry was that FM radio stations, MTV, and record stores performed a curatorial function.

They selected music and presented it to consumers.

Yes, that meant some deserving acts were undoubtedly left out.

But from the consumer’s perspective, the system offered an accessible selection of music that was still remarkably varied.

You didn’t have to sort through thousands of unknown bands to find something worth listening to.

You could turn on the radio, watch MTV, or walk into a record store and encounter a wide range of musical styles.

And many of those styles were supported by major record companies with the resources to develop and promote their artists.

That system had its limitations, but it also had some significant advantages.

The Problem Facing Independent Musicians

I follow a number of independent bands and musicians on YouTube.

And one thing I’ve noticed is that there are some extremely talented performers who seem to be stuck indefinitely performing cover material.

They can play the music of established artists exceptionally well.

But they don’t seem to have the institutional support necessary to develop, record, and promote their own original sound on a commercially significant scale.

To me, this is one of the most unfortunate aspects of the contemporary music marketplace.

I doubt that most talented young musicians want to spend their entire careers reprising songs that were popular when I was a teenager.

Surely many of them would like to develop their own musical identities and build audiences around their original work.

And as a listener, I’d like to hear that music, too.

I love AC/DC. But I’ve been listening to AC/DC for more than forty years.

I’d love to discover a new, commercially viable band with the distinctive sound and energy of AC/DC or Def Leppard.

I’m sure there are talented musicians out there who could produce something comparable.

But I don’t see them breaking into the mainstream marketplace.

Instead, we seem to get more Taylor Swift, more Olivia Rodrigo, and more performers working within a relatively narrow range of commercially successful styles.

So, Was 1980s Music Really Better?

I don’t believe that musical talent somehow peaked in the 1980s.

Nor do I believe that contemporary musicians are inherently less capable than the musicians of my generation.

My argument is really about the structure of the music industry and the incentives it creates.

The traditional music industry had plenty of flaws. But it also supported a surprisingly broad range of commercially successful performers.

The contemporary music marketplace was supposed to create more choice by removing the old gatekeepers.

And in one sense, it has done exactly that. There is more music available to consumers than ever before.

But availability and discoverability are two different things.

And having more music available doesn’t necessarily mean that listeners have an easier time finding music they’ll love.

The irony is that a marketplace designed to offer almost unlimited choice may have produced a narrower range of highly visible, commercially successful music.

So was music in the 1980s objectively better?

That’s ultimately a matter of personal taste.

But I would argue that the mainstream music industry of the 1980s offered a greater variety of distinctive musical experiences than the mainstream industry offers today.

And that’s one reason why so much music from that era remains popular more than forty years later.