Donovan’s Reef: John Wayne, John Ford, and a comedic adventure that goes awry

It’s fairly rare for me not to like a John Wayne movie. But I didn’t like Donovan’s Reef (1963), the Duke’s final collaboration with director John Ford.

There’s a story in here, but the movie is kind of a mess. And I didn’t care for the film’s Kennedy-era slapstick humor.

This is an unusual movie for John Wayne, starting with the premise. In Donovan’s Reef,  Wayne plays “Guns” Donovan, a World War II Navy veteran who runs a waterfront saloon on a French Polynesian island. His old shipmate “Boats” Gilhooley (Lee Marvin) comes ashore in time to observe their shared birthday in the usual fashion, with a barroom brawl. The third member of the group, “Doc” Dedham (Jack Warden), is the island doctor and the father of three children.

Then word comes from Boston that Doc’s grown daughter Amelia (Elizabeth Allen) is coming to the island. She has never met her father, and she wants to find out whether he’s fit to inherit a controlling interest in the family shipping company. With Doc away tending to patients on neighboring islands, Donovan decides to pass off the doctor’s three children as his own until Doc gets back.

Hijinks ensue. So, too, does the romance plot between Wayne and his much younger female costar (a predictable formula in most of Wayne’s later films).

Regular readers will know that political correctness for its own sake is not my shtick. Golden Age American cinema often portrays Native Americans, Asians, and other minorities in ways that would not be acceptable today. It’s fine to acknowledge that; but if you’re going to be clutching pearls throughout an entire film, it’s not worth the trouble of watching it.

Donovan’s Reef, however, overflows with Orientalism that must have been clichéd even for its time. The film contains scores of jabbering, grinning Asian stereotypes. This was an attempt at comedy. I don’t have a problem with politically incorrect comedy so long as it’s funny. The racial clichés in Donovan’s Reef seldom produced much humor.

The film contains far too many unnecessary fight scenes between Wayne and Lee Marvin… between Wayne and drunken sailors… etc.

The one high point in the movie is some of the dialogue between John Wayne and Elizabeth Allen. I wish this part of the movie had been more developed.

***

Like I said at the outset, this movie had some potential. I had the impression throughout that John Ford couldn’t decide what kind of movie he wanted to make. In 1963, the film was billed as a “big adventure.” Ford erred, in my opinion, when he decided to make Donovan’s Reef a comedy, too. Everything went awry from there.

-ET

Save on Amazon:

**View JOHN WAYNE: THE LIFE AND LEGEND by Scott Eyman on Amazon**